AED Economics 439 / IS 439
China's Economic Reforms and Development
Spring Quarter, 2006

 

 

Student Comments on Video 2 - Segment 2
Born Under the Red Flag
 

 
  1. What was the Democracy movement in China and the role of Hu Yaobang during the 1980s?

    • Young people were attracted to the openness movement.  Hu Yaobang was in touch with the people and the youth which began to question communism.  In 1986, Hu got Deng’s approval to implement political change against oldest members of the party – but the program was shelved.  Student demonstrations began against the government.  Hu Yaobang allowed demonstrates to return to school and not be arrested… conservatives outsted Hu Yaobang for being weak.  Students could no longer turn to Hu for protection.
    • Hu had the same questions about communism as the students and intellectuals.  In 1986 (with Deng’s support) initiated political reform by encouraging older members to retire.  Students were not satisfied with the pause in reforms caused by older conservatives so they held protests and demonstrations (1986) in Shanghai the demonstrators clashed with police and further demonstrations were banned.  Students returned to school but not in Beijing: despite police arrest and brutality Hu ordered them to be sent back to school and not jailed.  Hu was then ousted by conservatives.
    • He worked to get the oldest party members to retire and loosen party controls on many areas of life.  Hu also worked to understand the common man and rural people.  It was mainly founded in the university student population, they demanded being able to nominate local leaders and better jobs.  Hu worked to keep the students out of jail and instead had them bused back to school.
    • He wanted the older members of the party to retire.  He at first had the support of Deng but after awhile his support shifted to the older members of the party.  Hu Yaobang was more in touch with the people, that is why he fought for them so hard.
    • The movement at the university was called “Cultural Fever”.  Hu Yaobang was more in touch with the people, and was questioning communism.  As the heir apparent to the “throne”, Deng Xiaoping listened and agreed with him.  Hu wanted the older members of the party, but Deng had to appease the conservative side of the party.  He prevented the students from going to jail after Tienanmen Square (?), and was replaced.
    • Hu Yaobang began to question communist doctrine.  In 1986 Hu Yaobang under Deng Xiaoping was allowed to initiate political reform.  However, after senior members of the communist party began to question Deng the ideas of reform were shelved.  Hu Yaobang would later be ousted after helping students condemned during demonstrations.
    • Hu Yaobang wanted to loosen party control.  There was a western movement that wanted to allow free thinking.  The people wanted a say in elections.  They wanted to express themselves and have a say in what was going on.  Students were the majority.  Yaobang argued for the students.
    • Hu Yaobang in 1986 wanted to reform by letting go older communist leaders to allow younger and more liberal leaders.  He was ousted in 1987, the hardliners had their way.  Democracy movement wanted to elect local leaders and a more open school, so students protested with marches, sit-ins were met with more trouble.  Died April 19, 1989.
    • Hu Yaobang wanted older members of the party to retire and make way for new political reform.  Students moved toward political reform.  They began to take to rock’n roll and western art.  April 1989 died of heart attack.
    • The democracy movement started in campuses in major cities across China – thousands of students marched to have a choice in politics by candidates for local elections and having a say in their future careers.  Hu was the political leader who initiated this movement and attempted to protect students from police and he was later ousted for weak leadership.
    • The generations born under the red flag began questioning communism.  Rock music, art, etc. and China looking at the western world.  Hu Yaobang questioned communist dogma and had people thinking for themselves.  He worked to initiate political change.  Some thought he was too radical, 30,000 students marched in Shanghai holding demonstrations and stating their views.  Hu Yaobang was forced out of office b/c they felt he wasn’t handling things the way he should.  He was expelled from the communist party.
    • Dreams of political change.  Cultural fever, individualism, likeness of western culture.  Hu Yaobang was the heir apparent of Deng and shared views w/the masses of students.
    • Work for police change.  Young students demanded.  His views encouraged change.  They soon ousted him from office for not asking students to stand down.
    • Removing older members of parliament.   He tried to protect the students.
    • Western mucic and culture/ a shift from political to personal, more freedom to individuals thinking.  He wanted older people to retire and made students to protest which was a free speech.

 

 

   2.  When was China’s one child policy instituted?  What were its impacts on China?

    • The one-child policy was implemented in 1979. The hope was to limit a population surge.  In rural areas people wanted large families to farm the land.  Villagers became unhappy with family planning.  Women fled villages, others paid fines for having more than one child.  Family planning cut population growth by half.  Factories, however, couldn’t employ enough people as a result of econ. policy.
    • 1979.  in urban areas that were under closer supervision by the party, the policies were adhered to but in rural areas there was outraged backlash to the rigidity of enforcement.  The population growth overall was cut by half by the policy.
    • Many families were kept from having sons.  Sons are the guarantee that you will be taken care of in the future.  People were forced to have abortions and population growth was cut in half.  1979.
    • It was instated in 1979.  Women were forced to use contraceptives or have abortions.  Local police would take women to town on tractors to have their tubes tied.  This policy enraged farmers because they wanted someone to carry on the family name and that was their labor force.  It cut the population growth in half.
    • 1979.  The impact cut the population growth in half.  Still, a large population remained.  Many people wanted boys to take care of them when they became elderly.
    • 1979.  Women with 1 child had to use contraceptives.  Women would be forced to get tubes tied.  Farmers were enraged.  Women would secretly have kids or pay fines.  Cut population growth by half.
    • 1979 – villages and rural communities resisted the policy because traditionally they wanted sons and a big family.  A huge son preference developed because many older families were unable to sustain their living arrangements because of no social sec unity or social welfare.  Cut population by almost half.
    • 1989,  Women were told to use contraceptives and abortions were encouraged.  Women were later forced to have their tubes tied.
    • 1979; people especially in villages, became enraged.  There was great concern that families would not have a son to care for the elderly.  Ultimately population growth was cut by about half.
    • 1979 was when the China’s one child policy was instituted.  Many woman started getting abortions.  Families wanted boys b/c the boy would take care of their parents when they grew old.  The government was carting women to get their tubes tied and families were _____ and fled their villages to have their children.  Some were fined a good amount if they didn’t follow the policy.
    • One child policy began in 1979.  Family planning met resistance in rural areas.  Cut population growth by almost 50%.  Women had their ovarian tubes tied by force, not out of choice.
    • Too many people.  The feared too many people would make if difficult to maintain stability and feed the people./  Family planning was difficult in the family areas it was hard to enforce the family policies.  Neg impact on industries because people left farming to work in cities.
    • 1979.  Female children were in very low demand.  Population growth cut in half.
    • 1979.  Women with one child were pushed to use contraceptive and after one for abortion/ the push became too much, huge fines and gov started to control / cut pop growth by half the personal aspects of people’s lives.

       

 

  1. What where the causes of the Tienanmen Square Incidence?  What were its impacts on China?

  • In April 1989 Hu Yaobang died students anger exploded.  Students flocked to Tiananmen Sq. to make their voices heard against corruption and in favor of democratization.  Deng warned students against protesting, but students remained in Tiananmen Sq.  People refused to be intimidated and marched to Tiananmen Sq. and began a hunger strike.  On June 3, troops were forcing their way to the square and fighting broke out.  By June 4 students began heading home.  Many were arrested; some fled the country.

  • Inflation, corruption and the death of Hu Yaobang: a gathering in Tiananmen to commemorate his death turned into demonstrations about freedom of speech and the right to organize student organizations.  Deng condemned the students and warned them to stop this only caused more anger and students again marched to Tiananmen, they were joined by ordinary citizens, several hundred students held a hunger strike.  World press was in China to cover Gorbachev’s visit and the triumph of breaching the rift with the USSR turned into a huge embarrassment for Deng Ziaoping.  Thousands of protesters converged on Beijing.  Meant little to rural populations. Intnl. Corp. withdrew investments.
  • Hu Yaobang suffered a heart attach and died and the feelings of reform and demands for democracy were resurfaced.  Students came back to Tienanmen Square to pay tribute and protest.  Deng warned the students to not continue the protests.  In response the students came back anyway.  A hunger strike began.  At the same time Deng was embarrassed when Gorbachaz visited.  There was an attempt at negotiation but then martial law was imposed.  Two weeks the students kept the troops out.
  • The death of Hu Yaobang help start civil unrest.  Then it exculpated slowly with various incidents like the three students kneeling in front of the people’s shrine.  Then the article from Deng in the CC daily excelated the students.  People started going to Tienanmen.  It slowly got worse with people coming from all over the country.  Many investors called back their employees or cancel their investments in China.
  • Hu Yaoang died, and that reignited the feelings that he had believed.  After programs such as the Iron Rice Bowl and the one child policy had led to feelings of oppression, students wanted their voices to be heard.  Eventually workers and others who had once dared to speak out joined them in the square.  International gov’ts condemned China for cracking down on the leaders.  Businesses pulled their money and employees and the government applauded the army
  • Hu Yaobang passed away and many students rushed to Tiananmen Square for the memorial.  1,000 were there and began to voice their opinions yet no govt officials would meet them.  Later more protest would follow.  A hunger strike in Tiananmen would culminate the final protest.  Students would be joined by laborers and others.  Zhao Ziyang would eventually be ousted for supporting students.  Eventually martial law would be declared.
  • Government corruption and Hu Yaobang’s death, and the government’s condemnation of marching.  The students wanted to be heard.  The whole city was behind the students.  Movements all over the country started.  Everyone seemed to join.  Labor unions forced.  Martial law was declared.  Gov’t army opened fire on students.  International businesses scaled back employees.
  • The death of Hu Yaobang in April 1989.  Students were fed up w/corruption and back of freedoms.  Deng on  April 26 wrote in the newspaper for the students to end the protest that was “turmoil” but the students were not intimidated.  Students from all over joined in.  June 3 – 200 ppl died because of solider shots and student leaders were sentenced to prison terms.  Gorvbechev > Zhao banned by Hardliners > martial law.
  • The central committee rule the student movement as turmoil.  Students marched to Tienanmen Square and staged a hunger strike.  During this time Gorbachev visited and world press was in Beijing.  Troops began to force their way to the square using lethal force.  International businesses recalled employees and scaled down their presence in China.  Foreign nations condemned China’s treatment of these involved.
  • Inflation grew.  Corruption was rampant in the party and government.  People had no way to voice their concerns.
  • After Yaobang’s death students began an uprise again.  Govt’ labeled student movement turmoil.  Everyone started walking joining the movement.  Hu Yaobangs death caused the student movement.  Students felt they had to state their views and make sure the gov’t knew after his death.  The government labeled the student movement turmoil and wanted them to stop”starving for democracy”.  Later they then had a hunger strike.  Then students everywhere went on strike and they all joined the movement.
  • Students flocked here to pay tribute to Hu Yaobang.  They petitioned the central committee for more rights.  The gov’t condemned the movement.  Students began a hunger strike.  Gov’t arrested demonstrators.  4/26/89.  Gov‘t declared Marshall Law.  The army opened fir on the demonstrators.
  • Students wanted change.  They began to protest people joined them.  Teachers and intellectuals were expelled from the communist party.  Students were sent on BA jobs sent away.  Students once again returned to Tienanmen Sq. when Hu Yaobang
  • Beijing students protesting their inability to sit in at political events.  Growing social problems.
  • Gov didn’t cave to the students.  Students protested, they wanted an answer and discussion.  It was for democracy, began hunger strikes, other people started to demonstrate in other parts of the world.

    4.   What did Deng Xiaoping try to do after the Tienanmen Square

          Incidence in China?

 

    • On June 26, Deng congratulated the Army for a job well-done.  There was a huge crack-down against the leaders of Tiananmen Sq. incident; many were arrested.  The gov’t thought students should be re-educated.  Deng Xiaoping launched China into its most spectuvelas period of economic growth and called for improvement of living standards.  Jian Zemin addressed the party with the promise of huge foreign investment.  Economy soared and many became wealthy.
    • Congratulated the army for their actions and maintain that his actions and those of the party were valid.  Then in the early 90’s launched huge economic reform and stated that communism would not be saved by rhetoric but by economic improvement.  This led to the return of foreign investment and a boom in economic growth and communism saw its first millionaires.
    • He launched China into the most economically prosperous time to date.  Foreign investment returned and the Coastal regions grew rapidly.
    • Congratulated the Army on a job well done.  But even after the incident Deng still pushed for economic reform and successfully brought back investors Deng made his last public appearance at 90 years old.  One of the last of the old revolutionaries.
    • He wanted to install economic growth in the North, similar to what was happening in the south.  He thought that to save socialism, people’s lives had to increase and that rhetoric was not going to save them.  The focus had to be economic.
    • In the early 1990’s Deng Xiaoping would launch China into its largest period of economic growth.  Deng Ziaoping proclaimed that communism would not be saved with out economic growth.
    • He congratulated the army.  The incidence was seen as correct.  Students were to be re-educated.  Wanted to work on economic reform.  Communism will be saved by better living standards.  Foreign investment would return.
    • June 26 – Deng congratulated Army for a job well done.  After he went to Shenzhen and hoped ppl would follow in their example of making the economy work and prosper before giving political rights.  Can to make money, but peasants roamed land in hopes of getting some of the jobs or opportunities available.  Deng out 1994.  Died 1997.
    • He launched the entire country into reform to become like Shenzhen.  He also said the only way to get better was to improve life in China.
    • He tried to continue to push economics reform and increase people’s living standards; while continuing to repress political reform, the new economic policies caused foreign investors to return to China.  Peasant population suffered; gap widened.
    • He was aired on TV and congratulated the Army for a job well done in stopping the student movements.  He said that communism will be saved by bettering people’s living standards and called on all of China to be more like Shenzhen.  The countries economy began to soar.  Communism first millionaires were born, but many stayed poor.  PLA – was supposed to serve the people but they had open fired.
    • Many were sent to prison some students escaped and left the country.  Economic reform cont.  Companies from outside China to invest in China.  All this improvement did not do much for the people such as the farmers and other areas.
    • He tried to put student to work in separate small villages.  Leaders were arrested.
    • After 5 days of hunger the gov started to negotiate.  He came to the square and apologize and party bared him from public life.  200 people died/ gov arrested people who joined the protests/ int business returned for their employees/ he thanked the policy for the well job economic zone  for refoundation and modernization, foreign invest returned.


 

 

Top of Page

[Home] [Syllabus] [Term Paper] [Video Comments]
[MidTerm Review Questions]